Snap, crackle and flour

Good morning. Did you have Rice Krispies this morning? If you did, and the box was bought in the last few weeks, you might have noticed they were a shade paler than usual, a touch floury, and that they gave up in the milk rather sooner than they used to.

You weren't imagining it.

Back in September I wrote about two pouches of pad Thai sauce I found in the cupboard, bought a few months apart. One was out of date, which I will own, and which is the only reason I read the back of both. Same name, same front, same price. On the back, the sugar was down by 30%, the tamarind that gives the stuff its character had been halved, the salt had gone up and the protein had gone down. I made the point then, and I'll make it again now, that none of this was a criticism of the manufacturer. It is what a sensible business does when an input doubles in price and the supermarket won't take a penny on the shelf price. You change the recipe, not the ticket.

What I didn't expect was that one of the biggest names in British breakfast would make the same point for me within two months, and on the front of the box rather than the back of a pouch.

So, what has Kellogg's actually done? Rice Krispies no longer contain grains of rice. They contain rice flour. Coco Pops now contain a mixture of rice flour and corn flour. Both recipes also now contain wheat gluten, which means the allergen line has moved from "may contain gluten", the usual cover for a shared factory, to "contains wheat gluten", which means it was put in on purpose. If you have a wheat allergy, a cereal that used to be open to you no longer is.

Kellogg's says the change is down to the weather affecting the quality and availability of the rice and grains it uses, and that the new recipes have been tested for taste, texture and appearance and are just as good for you. I have no reason to doubt that the weather has been unkind to rice. The Grocer, meanwhile, reports that sales of Rice Krispies were already falling, in both volume and value, before any of this happened.

Now, a word about value engineering, because it is not a term of abuse, or at least it wasn't meant to be. It came out of General Electric in the 1940s, when wartime shortages forced engineers to ask of every component what it did, what it cost, and whether something cheaper would do the same job. The test, if you are being strict about it, is that the customer can't tell. A cheaper bracket that holds the panel just as well is value engineering. Shrinkflation is its crude cousin: same price, smaller pack. Reformulation is the clever version, because the pack doesn't change at all and the work is done where most people never look.

The skill is in knowing which parts of a product carry the cost and which carry the value, and they are rarely the same parts. In my pad Thai sauce the tamarind carried the flavour and a good slice of the cost. In a Rice Krispie, the rice carries the name on the box.

The wheat gluten gives the game away. A traditional Rice Krispie is a whole grain of rice, cooked, dried and toasted until it puffs. It holds its shape because it is still a grain. A piece made from flour can't do that; it has to be pushed through an extruder, and a flour dough needs a protein to bind it and let it expand. That is what the gluten is for. Extrusion is quicker, cheaper and a great deal less fussy about what you feed it. Puffing whole grain wants a consistent medium-grain rice, crop after crop. Flour can be milled from any grade, from anywhere, and topped up with maize where the brand allows. The weather is a real problem for the first process. A new extrusion line is precisely the thing that makes it stop being a problem.

Then there is the timing. Kellogg's shut Trafford Park in September after 88 years and moved production to Wrexham, where £75 million has gone into new lines and output is going up to around 1.5 million boxes a day. Mars bought Kellanova, the company that owns Kellogg's cereals outside America, last December for about $36 billion, a good deal of it borrowed. Put a new owner with interest to pay, a new factory built for speed and a heritage brand losing volume in a row, and I suspect most boards would have arrived at the same place.

None of which is wrong. It is just the arithmetic.

Now, you may be wondering what any of this has to do with a firm of solicitors in Shrewsbury, a lettings agent in Ludlow or a surveyor in Oswestry. Quite a lot, I think, because a professional practice has an ingredient deck too. It is just written on a timesheet rather than the back of a box.

The rice is the person the client thinks they are buying. The flour is whoever actually does the work. The gluten, the thing that holds the job together when a less experienced pair of hands is doing it, is the template, the precedent bank or the case-management system. And the front of the box, the bit that never changes, is the letterhead, the fixed fee and the engagement letter.

David Maister wrote the book on running a professional firm. Literally: it is called Managing the Professional Service Firm, it is more than thirty years old and it is still the best thing on the subject. He said that every practice is one of three things. A brains practice, where the client has a problem nobody has seen before and is paying for sheer cleverness. A grey hair practice, where the problem has been seen before and the client is paying for the fact that you have seen it. And a procedure practice, where the problem is routine and the client is paying for it to be done efficiently and without fuss. All three are honourable. They have different staff, different fees and a different number of juniors per partner, and Maister's warning was that the trouble starts when a firm sells one and delivers another.

That is the Rice Krispies trick, applied to a service. Take conveyancing. The fee has been pushed down for twenty years by online factories, and the response in a great many firms has been to turn a grey hair job into a procedure job without telling anyone: pods of paralegals, a workflow system, and a solicitor whose name is on the letters and who supervises a caseload they never actually open. The front of the box still says solicitors. The client reads the back when a search is missed or a completion slips.

Property has its own versions. The lettings agent's "fully managed" service where the quarterly inspection has quietly become an annual one and the maintenance call now goes to a call centre in another county. The estate agent whose accompanied viewings and professional photography have become a key safe and a phone number. The surveyor whose homebuyer report is now, if you read the small print, a desktop exercise. In each case the ticket is the same and the product is thinner, and in a county the size of this one the person who notices has told six people at the rugby club by Saturday.

Maister had a formula for this too, and it is the best one-line explanation of a customer complaint I know: satisfaction is perception minus expectation. The front of the box sets the expectation. Whatever has happened at the back sets the perception. Kellogg's and the conveyancing pod have made exactly the same bet, which is that the gap won't be noticed, and the reviews on Tesco's website suggest it is not a bet that pays for very long.

So what is the honest version? Maister's again: be clear about which kind of practice you are, and price it and staff it accordingly. Value engineer the procedure to your heart's content. The searches, the document assembly, the inspection diary, the admin of a transaction: none of it is why the client chose you and all of it should be done as cheaply as competence allows. That is the bracket that holds the panel just as well. But the half hour where somebody who understands the client tells them something they did not know, the grey hair, is the rice. A firm that cuts the first is well run. A firm that cuts the second, keeps the fee and keeps the letterhead is making Rice Krispies out of flour, and will find out what that tastes like at about the same pace Kellogg's is.

It is also harder to put right than it looks. Kellogg's in South Africa tried the same thing in 2018, got the same reaction, and had the original back on the shelf eighteen months later, imported from here. A firm that has let its grey hair go cannot import it back from Manchester. Maister's last book was called Strategy and the Fat Smoker, on the grounds that every firm knows perfectly well what it should be doing and most of them don't do it. I suspect most of the firms I have described would recognise themselves, and will do nothing until the reviews start.

And if you are the client rather than the practice, the lesson is the one I offered in September about the new school food standards. Specify the ingredient, not the headline. Ask who will actually do the work, and how often you will hear from them, before you sign. A quote that is still fixed fee, still regulated and still on the same letterhead has kept every promise on the front of the pack. Just make sure it hasn't lost the rice.

Snap, crackle and pop all made the move to Wrexham. Only the rice didn't.

Adrian Barker, Managing Director of CBSL Group, 3rd November 2026

 

*Sources: The Grocer, 3 November 2026; Kellogg's UK statement as reported by FOODbible, 2 November 2026; ITV Granada and Just Food on the Trafford Park closure and Wrexham investment; Mars and Kellanova completion announcement, 11 December 2025; TimesLIVE on the 2018 South African reformulation; David H. Maister, Managing the Professional Service Firm (1993) and Strategy and the Fat Smoker (2008).